針對不同種類的研究問題,研究者會利用各種不同的研究方法、資料來回答。許多研究方法的書都列了研究問題種類與研究方法的對照表,我下面列的是摘自 Yin (2009) 的 case study reserach (這本書有 kindle 版)。
Methods | Form of research question | Requires control of behavioral events? | Focus on contemporary events? |
Experiment | how, why? | yes | yes |
Survey | who, what, where, how many, how much? | no | yes |
Archival analysis | who, what, where, how many, how much? | no | yes/no |
History | how, why? | no | no |
Case study | how, why? | no | yes |
定義研究問題可說是作研究中最重要的一步,要了解到研究問題必須同時包含實質 (substance, 也就是你的研究是關於什麼的) 與形式 (forms, 像是 who, how, why, what, where 等)。
但具體的研究問題是什麼,很可惜 Yin (2009) 指出一個方向。沒關係,Miles and Huberman (1994) 這本質化資料分析的經典作 Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook,給出了一些可能考的方向。雖然這是重在質化研究,但我覺得量化研究在某種程度上也可以參考參考。
Sample questions | General form |
Causal-research Do children read better as a result of this program? Do children read better in this program as compared with other program? |
Does X cause Y?
Does X cause more of Y than Z cause of Y? |
Noncausal-research What is the daily experience of the children participating in this program? Are the remedial centers located in the areas of primary need? |
What is X?
Is X located where Y is lowest? |
Noncausal-policy What do we mean by “special education children” and “remediation”? Is this program receiving support from state and local officials for political rather than educational reasons? |
What does “Y” mean?
Why does S support X? |
Noncausal-evaluation What are the characteristics of the best CAI materials being used? How do the various minority groups view this program and judge its quality? |
What makes W good?
Does T value X? |
Noncausal-management What is the cost-effectiveness of the program compared with other programs? How can we maximize the scheduling of classes at the centers with minimum expense? |
Is X more cost-effective than Z?
How are U maximized and V minimized simultaneously? |
由於這部分英文還不難,但是不太好翻譯,所以我就原汁原味的呈現出來。另,網友告知 Miles and Huberman (1994) 這本書有中文版,書名為質性研究資料分析,有興趣的可以看看。
參考文獻
Miles, M. B., & Huberman, A. M. (1994). Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Yin, R. K. (2009). Case study research: Design and methods (4th ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
這頁碼是? 謝謝。